← Back to Mattress University

How to Choose the Right Mattress for Your Sleeping Style 

A good night’s sleep starts with a mattress that fits your body — but with so many options out there, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed. The truth is, the best mattress isn’t about chasing trends or buying the most expensive model. It’s about finding the one that supports your sleep style so you can wake up rested, pain-free, and ready for the day.

At Blackberry Creek Mattress, we’ve guided thousands of High Country sleepers through this process. Here’s what you need to know.

Step 1: Identify Your Sleep Position

Everyone sleeps differently, and your position plays a huge role in what mattress will feel right for you.

• Side Sleepers → Need pressure relief on hips and shoulders. A medium or plush mattress helps prevent those sore spots.

• Back Sleepers → Benefit from firmer support to keep the spine in healthy alignment and reduce lower back pain.

• Stomach Sleepers → Need a supportive, firm feel to keep hips from sinking and throwing off posture.

👉 Not sure what category you fall into? Many people are “combination sleepers.” In that case, a medium comfort level or hybrid option often works best.

Step 2: Choose the Right Firmness

Mattress firmness isn’t just about soft vs. firm — it’s about how your body feels when you lie down and how you feel when you wake up.

• Too soft → You may sink in and wake up sore.

• Too firm → Pressure points build up, leaving you tossing and turning.

• Just right → Balanced comfort + support for your preferred sleep position.

Our staff helps you test comfort levels in-store without pressure, so you can feel confident in your choice.

Step 3: Understand Mattress Materials

Different materials deliver different sleep experiences:

• Memory Foam → Contours closely, great for pressure relief.

• Latex → Naturally responsive, cooler, and durable.

• Innerspring → Traditional, supportive, with a bit of bounce.

• Hybrids → Combine coils + foam for the best of both worlds.

At Blackberry Creek, we carry trusted brands like Tempur-Pedic, Stearns & Foster, Sealy, Casper, Helix, Southerland, and Englander, so you can explore multiple feels side by side.

Want to compare feels in person? Visit Foscoe or Boone Mall—or browse our mattresses.

Why Shopping Local Matters

Buying a mattress online can feel like a gamble. But when you shop local, you don’t have to guess. You’ll:

• Try mattresses in person with guidance from our knowledgeable staff.

• Get peace of mind with our 120-Night Comfort Trial (with protector).

• Enjoy fast, local delivery and old mattress disposal.

• Support a local team that has helped High Country families sleep better for over 20 years.

As one customer told us:

“They listened to what I needed and guided me without being pushy. We finally feel confident in our choice.”

Find the Mattress That Fits You

The best mattress for you isn’t the one with the fanciest features — it’s the one that makes you feel at home in your own bed. Visit Blackberry Creek Mattress in Foscoe or the Boone Mall, and let us help you match your sleep style to the right mattress. You’ll leave knowing you made the right choice — and you’ll feel it every morning when you wake up refreshed.

Start Your Mattress Search →